10 Comments
User's avatar
Tolu Grey's avatar

Isnt there a downplaying of social media as THE e-commerce market Nigerians chose, as opposed to dedicated e-commerce platforms? Business didn't stay offline in my view, it moved online but not where we expected. And since bank transfers dominate these transactions, the payment processors that should be positioned to benefit from an e-commerce boom are bypassed completely. So many Instagram businesses with and without physical stores. The framing that businesses haven't moved online or e-commerce didn't show up doesn't align with the lived reality of Nigerians. What is clear is that the commerce didn't take the shape and form that these players expected. Those best positioned to capture it, as has played out, are those who built business and consumer banking, not those who only wanted to take their processor fees and be on their jolly way.

Abubakar Idris's avatar

I already explained this nuance in the article: "Everything remained offline, away from organized storefronts. Yet that didn’t mean people didn’t shop online.

Once a consumer sees a local product while doomscrolling on Instagram, they message the seller, haggle or reach a price, wire the money to the seller via bank transfer, while the seller dispatches the item to the customer using a third-party logistics service. In this transaction loop, from product discovery to consumer payment, e-commerce platforms received zero revenue, and payment providers got nothing. Yet an online trade concluded successfully, but via social commerce and peer-to-peer transfers."

Tolu Grey's avatar

The comment wasn't that it wasn't mentioned but it is downplayed. Repeatedly saying businesses stayed offline and those who chased offline did better, and online as only when it is organised storefronts a la e-commerce, downplays social commerce as THE online route the market chose. I'm saying it's not a sidebar nuance and I agree to disagree 👍🏾

Abubakar Idris's avatar

Nigeria's embrace of social commerce is an anomaly caused by the inefficiencies of existing storefronts. (A key premise of this article.) It's a very messy and informal way to do e-commerce.

All the features that make e-commerce scale successfully for buyers and sellers — such as product discovery, inventory management, business analytics, payments, product quality control, user reviews, anti-fraud mechanism, merchant product ads, among others — are missing or fragmented in Nigeria's mainstream social commerce practices. In short, it doesn't work well.

The existence of platforms like Selar tackle one aspect of the market (digital products) and that's good. But there's room for innovation. This is what Remita, Paystack Store and Flutterwave Store were aiming to solve, but things worked out differently. (The lede of the article.)

Fintechs like Moniepoint and Paystack recognize these inefficiencies and that's why they're bundling several business tools for merchants, especially those who sell largely offline and have no idea how these tools can transform their business. Whether these businesses go social commerce, digital store front, or remain offline, these fintechs are poised win on the back of this relationship with merchants. That's the big picture.

Tolu Grey's avatar

But isnt that the Nigerian way of things? It isn't an anomaly. Cards didn't get ubiquitous, and transfers took off. ATMs didn't reach scale and we today use POS terminals in its place. Mom and pop store are now operating as mini banks since commercial banks didn't do branch expansion en masse.

The features you mention that make e-commerce scale are not useful for fragmented, mostly single-employee businesses, which dominate the current social commerce space and, by extension, Nigeria's trade sector. Thus, those bundling merchant businesses tools now (Moniepoint) are targeting very specific businesses, a smaller category of offline-first, medium-sized businesses that have larger footfall and turnover.

What the paystack and Flutter stores attempted to solve for relies on an already successful e-commerce market. A market where the ecommerce players were struggling, a la Jumia and Konga, was not going to see success with storefronts.

Nigeria's "anomalies" need to be treated as what they are, the country's default. They are the constraints within which innovators can work, and they can't continually be treated as footnotes or sidebars to fit the global context.

David Schmidt's avatar

Fascinating piece. The social commerce loop - discovery on Instagram, payment via bank transfer - is something that doesn't show up in traditional payment metrics. Fintechs that figured out how to get back into that value chain with open banking made a smart bet.

Christina Nwabugo's avatar

Kmt. I want to write what I think but I can’t remain intellectually honest lmao. I hate when I enter an uber and I’m told to do OFFLINE? Bruh.

Abubakar Idris's avatar

I'd say this is a different problem than the fintech one we're discussing. This Uber "offline" trend is essentially fraudulent behavior by drivers who are trying to avoid paying platform commissions. It's not a fintech problem. Uber just has to find a way to punish errant drivers.

Young Skywalker's avatar

Great to call out that the e-commerce + payments boom never materialised. I wonder long term if they succeed in moving more payment activities from offline to online. - Are they doing the hard work of onboarding and customer acquisition for the banks